Victims Silenced by Loopholes in Workplace Harassment

November 16, 2018

 

Thousands of employers across the nation are sneaking a loophole into employment contracts called “forced,” “binding” or “mandatory arbitration.” This fine print prevents employees from suing companies in court for discrimination, sexual harassment and even assault, then prohibits victims from speaking publicly about their ordeals. Meanwhile, the federal government looks the other way .

 

Major revelations of  sexual harassment in the workplace  have started a long-overdue movement to protect all workers, but most often women, from a long history of abuse. You would think our major corporations would be taking the lead in stamping out these injustices. Instead, way too many are actually doing the opposite by writing “forced arbitration” clauses into employment contracts that prevent an employee from taking action in court. Instead, harassment disputes are forced into closed arbitrations that almost always favor the company and hide the outcome from the public. This has to stop!

 

A study by the  Equal Employment Opportunity Commission estimates  that anywhere from 25 percent to 85 percent of women report having experienced sexual harassment in the workplace. The number fluctuates because the Commission says 75 percent of abuse incidents go unreported. Many employees fear retaliation if they speak out, including the loss of their jobs. The Commission also points out that forced arbitration weakens “an employer’s incentive to proactively comply with the law.”

Forced arbitration clauses not only protect abusers from a court of law but also silence employees from speaking publicly once through arbitration. Gretchen Carlson, a former Fox News anchor, sued Fox News after she was fired for allegedly refusing sexual advances from Fox News Chairman Roger Ailes. Fox attempted to have her claims adjudicated in closed-door mandatory arbitration instead of court, effectively requiring that the details of her case be legally hidden from the public. Since settling her lawsuit with Fox News, Gretchen Carlson has been an advocate for legislation that prohibits forced arbitration clauses in employment and consumer contracts.

Legislation the Next Step

Outlawing forced arbitration clauses in employee contracts as a protection for American workers seems like a logical step, yet those protections are under attack. Last year, the Administration repealed  an executive order  safeguarding employees of federal contractors from forced arbitration clauses in their employment contracts. Congress then  canned a new regulation  from the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau that would have stripped forced arbitration clauses from contracts for financial services, like checking accounts and investment services. Recent Supreme Court decisions also have upheld the broader use of forced arbitration clauses in consumer contracts.

More encouraging was the announcement by Microsoft last December that it would eliminate forced arbitration clauses in employment agreements, showing that the flood of harassment accusations has gone beyond individual cases to inspire changes in corporate policy. However, given opposition by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce to closing this loophole, it is unlikely that most other major corporations will follow suit.

Thus, a bipartisan group from both the U.S. House and Senate has introduced legislation to ban arbitration clauses in harassment cases from all employment contracts. Called the  Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Harassment Act , this bill “prohibits a pre-dispute arbitration agreement from being valid or enforceable if it requires arbitration of a sex discrimination dispute.” Our hope is that with support from both sides of the aisle, this law will be passed to give those who have been sexually harassed or abused on the job their rightful day in a real court of law.

If you are facing sexual harassment then contact the Law Office of Mark Nicholson at 317-667-0718

This article was produced by the Glaser and Ebbs law firm and used with their permission.

source:  let america know

Week five Puff Daddy trial updates
By Mark Nicholson June 18, 2025
As we enter the fifth week of Sean "Diddy" Combs' high-profile trial, the courtroom continues to be a theater of shocking revelations and unexpected developments. From damning testimony about alleged "freak offs" to a juror getting the boot!
Puff Daddy Jury Trial week 4
By Mark Nicholson June 9, 2025
As week four of Sean "Diddy" Combs' sex trafficking trial unfolds, the courtroom has transformed into a battlefield of explosive testimony, fierce defense strategies, and judicial warnings.
Week 3 Puff Daddy Trial
By Mark Nicholson June 2, 2025
Week 3 Review: The gloves are off as former assistant "Mia" delivers devastating testimony against Sean "Diddy" Combs. She detailed alleged sexual assaults, physical abuse, and controlling behavior.
Puff Daddy trial updates for week 2
By Mark Nicholson May 27, 2025
WEEK 2 OF THE DIDDY TRIAL: The courtroom drama intensifies as witnesses reveal disturbing details about alleged "freak offs" - drug-fueled sex performances that prosecutors claim were part of a criminal enterprise.
Expungement law Indiana
By Mark Nicholson May 26, 2025
Navigate the process of expungement in Indiana with our essential guide. Discover how to clear your record effectively and move forward confidently.
Indianapolis Self-Defense attorney
By Mark Nicholson May 20, 2025
In Indianapolis, the echo of gunshots has become an all-too-familiar sound. From bus stops to neighborhood corners, recent shootings across the city aren't just crime statistics—they're complex legal cases.
Puff Daddy on Trial
By Mark Nicholson May 19, 2025
The first week of Sean "Puff Daddy" Combs' high-profile jury trial has delivered explosive testimony, dramatic courtroom moments, and legal strategies that deserve closer scrutiny.
Indiana Black Civil Rights Attorney
By Mark Nicholson May 17, 2025
Indiana Black Civil Rights Attorney Mark Nicholson will fight for your rights. Read this article to learn more about why it is important to have an attorney help you when your rights have been violated.
Indiana Civil Rights Attorney
By Mark Nicholson April 18, 2025
Why do you need a dedicated civil rights attorney to fight for your rights? If you or a loved one had their rights violated by the police, then you need to read this article and find out.
Is Abortion Legal in Indiana? Indianapolis Abortion lawyer
By Mark Nicholson March 30, 2025
Discover if is abortion legal in Indiana. Get all the essential information on the laws and regulations surrounding abortion in Indiana.
More Posts