What They Won't Tell You About MedPay After a Car Accident

The "Stacking" Secret They Don't Want You to Know

Here's where insurance companies really try to screw you over. Let's say you're a passenger in your friend's car when they get T-boned by some idiot running a red light. You get hurt. Badly.



Your insurance company might grudgingly process your MedPay claim from your own policy. What they won't tell you? You can also claim MedPay benefits from your friend's insurance policy. That's right: double coverage.

This is called "stacking," and it can literally double your available medical coverage. If you both have $10,000 in MedPay coverage, you could have access to $20,000 in medical benefits. But insurance companies will never volunteer this information because it means they have to pay out more money.

I've seen families miss out on tens of thousands in legitimate benefits simply because nobody told them they could stack coverage. Don't let this happen to you.

The "Primary Coverage" Advantage That Saves You Thousands

Here's another dirty little secret: MedPay can act as your primary medical coverage for accident-related injuries. What does this mean in plain English? No co-pays. No deductibles. No fighting with your health insurance company.

When MedPay is primary, you walk into the doctor's office, show them your MedPay information, and get treated without paying a dime upfront. Your regular health insurance never even gets involved for accident-related care.

This is massive for two reasons:

1. Immediate care without financial barriers - You don't need to choose between getting medical attention and protecting your bank account
2. Settlement protection - Since your medical bills are already paid through MedPay, they don't get deducted from any personal injury settlement you might win later

Insurance companies hate when people understand this because it means they can't use your medical debt as leverage during settlement negotiations.

Why Your Doctor Might Reject Your MedPay (And What to Do About It)

Here's a frustrating reality: not all doctors accept MedPay. Why? Because dealing with auto insurance companies is a pain in the ass, and many healthcare providers would rather just deal with regular health insurance.

This creates a catch-22 where you have coverage you can't use with the doctors you want to see. Insurance companies know this and count on it to reduce their payouts.

The solution: Find doctors who specialize in treating car accident victims. These providers understand MedPay billing and have systems in place to handle the paperwork. Personal injury attorneys like myself maintain networks of these doctors specifically for this reason.

Don't let your insurance company off the hook just because your regular doctor won't accept MedPay. There are options.

The "One Year Rule" They Hope You Forget

In Indiana, you typically have one year from the date of your accident to use your MedPay benefits. Miss that deadline, and your coverage expires: forever.



Insurance companies love this rule because people often don't realize they're injured immediately after an accident. Adrenaline masks pain, and some injuries don't show symptoms for days or weeks. By the time you figure out you need medical attention, you might be close to that one-year deadline.

Pro tip: Start your MedPay claim immediately after any accident, even if you think you're fine. You can always add medical expenses later as they arise, but you can't go back in time if you miss the deadline.

The "Pre-Authorization" Trap

Some insurance companies require pre-authorization for certain MedPay benefits, especially for things like physical therapy or specialized medical equipment. They'll conveniently forget to mention this requirement, then deny your claim months later because you didn't get approval.

This is a deliberate delay tactic designed to frustrate you into giving up on your claim. Don't fall for it.



Always ask about pre-authorization requirements upfront, and get any approvals in writing. Better yet, have an attorney handle your MedPay claim from the start to avoid these bureaucratic traps.

How Much MedPay Should You Actually Have?

Insurance companies love selling you the minimum MedPay coverage: usually $5,000 in Indiana: because it keeps your premiums low and their liability limited. But $5,000 doesn't go far in today's medical environment.

One emergency room visit can eat up half that coverage. An ambulance ride, some X-rays, and basic treatment can max out $5,000 coverage before you even know what's wrong with you.

My recommendation for Indiana drivers: Carry at least $25,000 in MedPay coverage if you can afford it. The premium difference between $5,000 and $25,000 coverage is usually less than $10 per month, but the protection difference is enormous.

When Insurance Companies Flat-Out Refuse to Pay

Sometimes insurance companies will simply deny your MedPay claim, hoping you'll give up and go away. Common excuses include:

• "Your treatment wasn't related to the accident"
• "You waited too long to seek treatment"
• "We need more documentation"
• "This isn't covered under your policy"

Most of these denials are bogus, but they're counting on you not knowing that. This is where aggressive legal advocacy becomes crucial.

Why You Need an Attorney Who Fights Dirty

Insurance companies have teams of lawyers whose only job is finding ways to deny or minimize your claims. They have investigators, medical experts, and decades of experience screwing over accident victims.



You need someone in your corner who understands their tactics and isn't afraid to fight fire with fire. At the Law Office of Mark Nicholson, we've been dealing with insurance company BS for years, and we know exactly how to make them pay what they owe.

We handle MedPay claims as part of our comprehensive car accident representation. That means we're working to maximize your MedPay benefits while also pursuing your personal injury claim against the at-fault driver.

The Bottom Line: Stop Getting Screwed

Your insurance company isn't looking out for you. They're a business, and their business model depends on collecting premiums and paying out as little as possible in claims.

But you don't have to take it lying down. Understanding your MedPay rights is the first step toward getting the coverage you've paid for. Fighting for those rights: aggressively: is how you actually get paid.

If you've been in a car accident in Indiana and your insurance company is giving you the runaround on your MedPay claim, don't wait. Every day you delay is another day they can find new ways to deny or reduce your benefits.

Call the Law Office of Mark Nicholson today. We don't get paid unless you get paid, and we're not afraid to make insurance companies uncomfortable until they do the right thing.

Your insurance company has lawyers. Shouldn't you?