Were you driving while Black and stopped by the Blue? Then call the Law Office of Mark Nicholson and he will help you through. Racism is not dead and it will rear its ugly head. But by fighting it together we can get ahead. Don’t give up and don’t give in. Just hire an attorney to help you win!
Carmel Police Ticket Black Drivers at Higher Rate
CARMEL, Ind. (WISH) — Court data obtained by I-Team 8 revealed the color of your skin may increase the probability that several central Indiana police departments will give you a traffic ticket.
I-Team 8 obtained data on all the traffic tickets issued last year where the officer noted the driver’s race. We got the data from the state court system. We shared the data from the 11 different departments with a statistician to make sure all data points were statistically significant. I-Team 8 analyzed the data and found the largest disparities between tickets issued to black people and to white people was in Carmel.
Tamise Cross got a ticket from Carmel police last January. She was driving on a suspended license, but that is not why she said she was pulled over.
“I just pretty much was flowing with the traffic and then he just came up behind me, pulled me over, asked me if I realized I was speeding, and I told him I didn’t realize it,” said Cross. “I didn’t get a speeding ticket, so it ended up not being anything having to do with speeding.”
Cross said she felt uncomfortable and like she was being targeted.
“You just never really as an African American, you don’t want to feel like you’re going to get pulled over,” Cross said. “You don’t know if you’ll be the next story or anything like that.”
Micah Hillsman found himself in a similar position. Last December, Carmel police ticketed him for driving on a suspended license.
Is Race An Issue?
“It could have been because I was African American,” Hillsman said when we asked why he was pulled over. “When I went to go to court, there were nothing but blacks there, like 97 percent blacks. Like I told you before, it was nothing but blacks.”
Hillsman is scared to go to Carmel because of the experiences he and his friends have had there.
Most people who live in the Indianapolis bedroom community of Carmel are white – 84% of the population. Black people are only 2.5% of Carmel’s population, but account for more than 33% of the traffic tickets.
We took these numbers to Carmel Chief of Police Jim Barlow.
“I think our officers are trained to look at violations, not individuals, and I truly believe that’s what occurs,” said Barlow.
Racial bias by Carmel police is not new. In 1996, a black Indiana State Police sergeant was pulled over while driving to his house in Carme l
. Sgt. Smith sued the city of Carmel, along with the American Civil Liberties Union and other advocacy organizations.
In 2016, the city of Carmel settled with a black man who also alleged racial profiling when he was stopped by Carmel police.
Courtney Clenney says she threw a knife from 10 feet away. The medical examiner says the wound says otherwise. Is it self-defense or murder? What about in Indiana?
Being charged with domestic battery in Indiana is a serious matter. If you or someone you love is facing this charge, here's what you need to know about your rights.
An OVWI charge in Indiana can cost you your license, your job, and your freedom. If you've been pulled over and arrested for operating a vehicle while intoxicated...
Received a not guilty verdict in Indiana? Learn what this means for your criminal record, double jeopardy, and future. A guide from a criminal defense attorney.
Navigate the Indiana Rules of Evidence with a clear guide. Learn key rules, objections, and strategies for criminal defense & personal injury cases in Indiana.
Estimate your settlement with our Indiana car accident claim calculator. See how medical bills, lost wages, and 2026 state laws impact your total recovery.
Can a lawyer get a dui dropped? Explore how a lawyer can get a dui dropped in Indiana. Understand legal grounds for dismissal, and effective defense strategies.
Find the best personal injury attorney near me to navigate your claim confidently. Discover key qualities, local expertise, and how to secure fair compensation.
Learn what a Kink Aware Professional is, how they help without judgment, and why kink-aware legal support matters for privacy, revenge porn, and kink-shaming cases.
DISCLAIMER: Everything displayed on this site shall be regarded as general advertising and educational information and in no way should it be interpreted as legal advice. This does not create an attorney-client relationship. You should contact an attorney directly regarding your own situation. An attorney-client relationship will only be established after you hire us and we have established that there is no conflict of interest.
Mailing Address
9702 E. Washington Street, Suite 171 Indianapolis, IN 46229